TOPIC
Exclusion
From discriminatory legislation and the deprivation of rights to persecution and mass crimes: how regimes implemented policies of exclusion.
17
Timeline entries
02
Teaching resources
00
Repository sources
Entries
01
A Culture and Practice of Excluding “the Others”. The Status of Ethnic and Religious Minorities. An Overview
The traditional cultural, economic, and political antisemitism in the Old Kingdom, adopted by the state elites who systematically excluded Jews from the citizenry—including through constitutional measures until 1884—spread throughout all of Romania after World War I. Historical factors intertwined with the specific circumstances of the post-World War I period: the naturalization of Jews due to external pressure (reflected in the March 1923 Constitution), exarcebated nationalism caused by the new state reality—with minorities comprising approximately 30% of the population, the Bolshevik threat etc. Attempts to exclude "the Jew" from society—who was regarded as the quintessential outsider and blamed for the shortcomings of postwar reconstruction or the difficulties of building a “world of good”—were carried out primarily through state measures aimed at rebuilding the Romanian national community and through fascist-style political groups. The actions of these political, cultural, and religious actors became the standard for the marginalization of other minorities, such as ethnic or religious ones.
02
The Emergence of Political Extremism in Romania: A Program of Exclusion of ‘The Other’. The Coalescence of Far-Right Groups
In the early interwar years, in a unified Romania, against a backdrop of social discontent that had gradually intensified, there were multiple attempts to politically organize intellectual groups and channel popular nationalist, anti-Bolshevik, and antisemitic sentiments: on February 9, 1920, in Iași, the newspaper Garda Conștiinței Naționale [Guard of the National Conscience] was launched by the organization of the same name, led by the worker Constantin Pancu and the student Corneliu Zelea Codreanu, in which the programmatic article “The Creed of National-Christian Socialism” was published; other groups emerged in Bucharest and Cluj: inspired by the movement led by Benito Mussolini, the Fascia Română, led by Titus Panaitescu Vifor (an antisemitic, xenophobic, and militaristic figure who served as Romania’s commercial attaché in Belgium in the early 1920s and as cultural attaché in Italy in the early 1940s), Acțiunea Românească, Fascia Națională Română, led by Gheorghe Bădulescu (ambassador and military attaché to Japan from 1934 to 1943, and a brigadier general during World War II), or the Italo-Romanian National Cultural and Economic Movement, founded in Cluj by Elena Bacaloglu, a journalist married to an Italian who sympathized with Mussolini. The latter two would merge to form the openly fascist Mișcarea Națională Fascistă [the National Fascist Movement]. In 1924, the group published Doctrina Fascismului Român [The Doctrine of Romanian Fascism], a virulently antisemitic and xenophobic program. These groups would later resurface in subsequent radical nationalist movements, particularly those led by A. C. Cuza. The new demographic realities of interwar Romania, where nearly 30% of the population belonged to minority groups, would be fiercely contested by these fascist currents.
03
Deportations. Transnistria as a Place of Rejection: Jews, Roma / The Issue of Homosexuals, “Sectarians,” and People with Disabilities
Beginning in the fall of 1941, the deportation to Transnistria—a territory under military administration, formally annexed by Romania (within the territorial boundaries of Romania proper, civil laws applied)—of Jews from Bukovina and Bessarabia (a total of 320,000) began, on the grounds that they had supported the Soviet Union and had engaged in looting and acts of cruelty against the Romanian population during the territorial concessions of the summer of 1940. Marshal Antonescu’s orders aimed to “cleanse the area” of foreign elements deemed potentially “hostile” or collaborating with the Bolsheviks. Although it was not a policy of direct extermination orchestrated by the Romanian state, approximately 140,000 Jews died in the camps of Transnistria (from starvation, cold, poor hygiene, disease [dysentery], exhaustion, and the arbitrary and brutal actions of the authorities—soldiers who showed leniency were punished) . Another 25,000 died along the way. Fifteen camps were established, the most notorious being Ahmetcetka, Bogdanivka, Domanivka, and Peciora.
04
Deportations. The Deportation of Gypsies/Roma to Transnistria
The exclusion of the Roma population from society is a defining feature of Romanian modernity. Although there were no formal measures against the Roma after 1918, the shock caused by the collapse of Greater Romania accelerated efforts to rebuild the national entity by eliminating the Roma. The criteria for exclusion were not based on a racial paradigm; instead, considerations of public and social order prevailed.
Initially, at the Council of Ministers meeting on February 7, 1941—when the issue of removing the Roma from Bucharest was first raised—Ion Antonescu proposed building compact villages in the Bărăgan Plain or in the Danube marshlands. Subsequently, the deportation of Roma to Transnistria—particularly the nomadic gypsies, who were relocated without exception (11,441 nomadic Roma) between June 1 and August 15, 1942—as well as the sedentary (non-nomadic) gypsies, deemed “unfit for mobilization” for certain types of labor (13,176 Roma). The operation was officially concluded on September 16, 1942. By December 1943, an additional 69 gypsies who had evaded the two previous waves—including those released from prisons and those placed on the authorities’ list of undesirables—were deported. Approximately 11,000 Roma perished in Transnistria.
05
The Marginalization of the Hungarian Minority. Hungarians and the Threat to Greater Romania: The Potential Danger of Revisionism
The Romanian state’s policy of “Romanianization” after 1918 marginalized the Hungarians / a policy of excluding former decision-makers / administrative harassment, language exams, and the oath of loyalty to the King of Romania and to the Romanian state.
Faced with Romanian policies, viewed as anti-minority and anti-Hungarian, the tendency among Hungarians to leave for Hungary.
Sándor Makkai, a university professor, writer, and Reformed bishop—a senator in the Romanian Parliament, spiritual mentor, and leader of the Transylvanian Hungarians after 1918—attempted to define a new identity for them within the Romanian state / as a gesture of openness toward Romanian society: forced to leave for Hungary (where he became a professor at the University of Debrecen), published “Nem lehet” [It Cannot Be] in the journal Láthatár, 2 / 1937, pp. 45–93.